Founded in 1864. An employee-owned company.

Pay Your Bill Online

Conveniently Pay Your Insurance Premium Online

Should you wish to make an online payment via this safe and secure online tool, please click on one of the links below. Our online bill payment tool is managed through Heartland Billing Solutions. Heartland Billing Solutions allows you to pay bills directly to Marshall & Sterling Insurance, including a new no-cost eCheck option

You may make any number of transactions to Marshall & Sterling during a single session. To protect your privacy and security, we do not store any sensitive personal financial information after processing your payment. For more information on Marshall & Sterling's privacy policies please click here.

Please click on the appropriate button below:

Master Risk Customers

  This option is for Premium Finance Customers only

Continental U.S. Branch Customers

  Invoices received from your carrier directly MUST be paid through their website

Equine Customers

  Invoices received from your carrier directly MUST be paid through their website
EMO Agency Customers Invoices received from your carrier directly MUST be paid through their website

St. Croix Branch Customers

  Invoices received from your carrier directly MUST be paid through their website

St. Thomas Branch Customers

  Invoices received from your carrier directly MUST be paid through their website

Please note...

  • Payments made after 1:00 pm (ET) will be credited the next business day
  • Insurance premiums billed directly by your insurance carrier CANNOT be made here. Visit the carrier website contained in your bill to make a direct payment.
  • COBRA payments CANNOT be made here. To pay your COBRA payment online please visit myRSC.com 
  • A small convenience fee is charged for credit cards, however eChecks are free of fees/surcharges.