Founded in 1864. An employee-owned company.

Personal Insurance

Protecting your home, auto, and other valuable possessions and personal belongings is always important. Marshall & Sterling Insurance offers a wide array of personal insurance coverages to help protect your most valued assets. Our Personal Lines Insurance Specialists work with you to develop an insurance program tailored to meet your individual needs. We have direct and preferred relationships with many of the leading insurance carriers in the nation, to provide you with great low rates and outstanding coverage.

GET A QUOTE FROM MIDDLETOWN          GET A QUOTE FROM MONTICELLO

Since 1864, when Abraham Lincoln was President, Marshall & Sterling Insurance has been providing exceptional personal insurance coverage with unparalleled service and support for our valued clients.  As an employee-owned company, our team of experienced insurance professionals can assist you with all of your personal insurance needs. Our pride in ownership drives us to be an insurance agency unlike any other. With 26 office locations, Marshall & Sterling Insurance can provide affordable personal insurance coverages, including:

  •     Homeowners  
  •     Condos & Renters
  •     Auto
  •     Motorcycle
  •     Boat and RV
  •     Life Insurance
  •     Personal Umbrella
  •     Equine
  •     Vacation Homes
  •     Antique Cars
  •     Collectibles
  •     Unique Risks

We are committed to exceeding every client’s expectation for quality insurance and customer service.

The biggest investment most people will ever make is their home. That’s why it makes sense to protect your investment, and your future, with a comprehensive homeowners plan.
These days, lawsuits related to vehicle accidents are very common. Ensure you have the best possible protection at the best rates by speaking with a Marshall & Sterling...
Umbrella insurance isn’t just for the wealthy anymore.