Founded in 1864. An employee-owned company.

Our Team

As one of the largest independent insurance agencies in the nation, our professionals are able to provide the industry expertise, attentive care and support each customer deserves. We are committed to exceeding each and every client’s expectation for quality insurance and customer service.

Have a positive experience with one of our team members? We want to hear from you!

Looking to join our team? View available opportunities!

Our team members in Middletown and Monticello are ready to help! Please reach out to us with questions about your account, or to learn more about our insurance programs.  
We welcome your feedback! Marshall & Sterling is committed to exceeding our client's expectation for quality and service. Please take a few moments to complete this brief 2-...
Marshall & Sterling Insurance is committed to being a strong community partner and playing a key role in corporate social responsibility within the communities we serve.