Founded in 1864. An employee-owned company.

Our Professionals

Our team members in Middletown and Monticello are ready to help! Please reach out to us with questions about your account, or to learn more about our insurance programs.
 

Greg Townsend
Vice President & Branch Manager
(800) 282-2138 x-2161
 

Email Greg   View Bio

 

Middletown Employees

Department

Title

Telephone

Ext.

Administration

     
Chelsea Northup Receptionist (845) 343-2138 x2150
Rhonda Smith (Marino) Manager of Operations & Insurance Services (845) 343-2138 x2158
Marketing      
Laurie Yonkin Marketing Assistant (845) 343-2138 x2179
Alyssa Tyler Marketing Assistant (845) 343-2138 x2166
Sales Staff      
Stephen Kalmus  [See Bio] Sales Executive (845) 343-2138 x2169
Robert Pilla  [See Bio] Sales Executive (845) 343-2138 x2160
Samantha Rheel  [See Bio] Sales Executive (Personal Lines) (845) 343-2138 x2264
Commercial Lines      
Hannah Corbett Assistant CSR (845) 343-2138 x2153
Maria Cruz CSR (845) 343-2138 x2176
Kristin Godino Asst. CSR (845) 343-2138 x2174
Crystal Lewis Commercial Lines Manager (845) 343-2138 x2156
Sonia Lewis Assistant CSR (845) 343-2138 x2152
Jennette Montgomery Assistant CSR (845) 343-2138 x2154
Lydia Negron CSR (845) 343-2138 x2172
Lori Parietti CSR (845) 343-2138 x2151
Personal Lines      
Wendy Mann Sr. CSR (845) 343-2138 x2157
Belinda Orr Sr. CSR (845) 343-2138 x2162
Liz Sukosky Sr. CSR (845) 343-2138 x2173
Claims      
Ruth Morris Claims Manager (845) 343-2138 x2159
Melissa Kearsing Commercial Lines Claims CSR (845) 343-2138 x2163
Sue Pullano Personal Lines Claims Assistant CSR (845) 343-2138 x2175

 

Monticello Employees

Department

Title

Telephone

Ext.

Program Management      
Irene Jones   [See Bio] Program Development Manager (845) 794-5544 x2603
Sales Department      
Brian Seigerman   [See Bio] Sales Executive (845) 794-5544 x2615
Commercial Lines      
Heather Bechelli CSR (845) 794-5544 x2612
Sharron Cardone CSR (845) 794-5544 x2609
Heather Carnesi Assistant CSR (845) 794-5544 x2604
Diana Foster-Glendon CSR (845) 794-5544 x2602
Personal Lines      
Missy Drobysh Sr. CSR (845) 794-5544 x2607
Kellee Whitehead CSR (845) 794-5544 x2606
Claims      
Sue Pullano Personal Lines Claims Assistant CSR (845) 794-5544 x2175