Founded in 1864. An employee-owned company.

Claims & Contact Information

Your insurance contract requires that you report all claims promptly. Therefore, contact us as soon as possible after a loss and we will report your claim to the insurance company and apprise you of what to expect next. An insurance company claims adjuster will be assigned to handle your claim and will be instrumental in settling your claim.

If you encounter any unusual delays or problems in the handling of your claim, please contact your claim representative below for assistance at 800-782-2926.

Marshall & Sterling insurance strives to provide unparalleled service and support for our clients. Get the information and services you need, when you need them, no matter where you are! During normal business hours, the following claims representatives will be happy to assist you:

Middletown Claims

Ruth Morris, Commercial Lines Claims
(845) 343-2138 x2159
 

Rhonda Marino, Manager of Operations & Insurance Services
(845) 343-2138 x2158

Monticello Claims

Gordon Sakow, Claims
(845) 794-5544 x2117
 

Ronni Yakin-Scannell, CSR
(845) 794-5544 x2608

Looking to contact your carrier directly? Click here.

Around the Clock Access and Assistance:

24/7 Toll Free Number for
Middletown & Monticello:

866-223-8984

Log-in to Online Client Portal

If you are a customer and wish to obtain access to this online tool, but do not yet have logon
information, please  contact your Marshall & Sterling Service Representative

   

Representatives from our call center can take your phone call at any time. In the event of a claim or emergency, our call center is here. If you have an insurance question or need to call or contact us outside of our normal business hours, and you are an existing customer and have obtained your logon and password, you may sign in by using these safe and secure web portal links.

Using our 24/7 Access, you can:

  • Print a list of vehicles, drivers or certificate holders
  • Obtain a Certificate of Insurance, even on weekends
  • Request a policy change online
  • Notify us of a claim or loss by specific location or vehicle