Founded in 1864. An employee-owned company.

Our Professionals

Our People Are Your Best Insurance

Our team members in Millbrook are ready to help! Please reach out to us with questions about your account, or to learn more about our insurance programs.


Cathy Shanks
Vice President & Branch Manager
(845) 677-3434 x-2706

Email Cathy   View Bio







Receptionist/Branch Assistant        
Nicole Baker Receptionist (845) 677-3434 x-2702 Email
Sales Staff        
Joe Grosse  [BIO] Sales Executive (845) 677-3434 x-2709 Email
Kelly Sherman  [BIO] Sales Executive (845) 677-3434 x-2714 Email
Karen Klippel Account Executive (845) 677-3434 x-2707 Email
George Whalen, III Sales Executive (845) 677-3434 x-2703  
Commercial Lines Department        
Kacey Bajcar CSR (845) 677-3434 x-2713 Email
Mary Liberatore Sr. CSR (845) 677-3434 x-2705 Email
Corey Martire CSR (845) 677-3434 x-2703 Email
Lynda Mastromarco CSR (845) 677-3434 x-2712 Email
Personal Lines Department        
Cindy Cobble CSR (845) 677-3434 x-2708 Email
Marcy Rutchik CSR (845) 677-3434 x-2713 Email
Linsey Wendover CSR (845) 677-3434 x-2718 Email
Claims Department        
  CSR (845) 677-3434 x-2719 Email