Founded in 1864. An employee-owned company.

Carrier Information

Need to contact one of our carriers directly? Below is a directory of our Commercial Lines and Personal Lines carriers, and how to reach them.

 

Commercial Insurance Company

Auto

Property

Liability

Workers Comp.

Disability

Acadia

T)866-497-4697    
F)866-874-5104
same same same  

ACE

    Email    

Allstate

T)800-359-1000    
F)866-862-0946
same same same  

Central Mutual

T)888-263-2924    
F)866-420-1404
same same same  

Central -
Emergency after hrs

T)877-346-0300        

Chartis (AIG)

      T)800-645-2259
F)866-420-1404
 

Chubb

T)800-252-4670    
F)800-300-2538
same same same  

CNA

T)877-262-2727   
F)800-953-7389

same same T)800-262-6344
F)800-742-7209
T)800-303-974
F)407-919-6329

CNA Human Resource Policies

T)800-262-4213 
F)888-577-1690

same same same T)800-303-9744
F)407-919-6329

Eastern Mutual

  T)800-367-3242
F)518-966-5022
same same  

Erie & Niagara

  T)800-234-9876
F)716-632-9621
same    

Firemans Fund

T)800-870-8857  
F)888-323-6450
same same same  

Firemans Fund -
Emergency

T)888-347-3428 same same    

First Cardinal

      T)518-213-1900
F)518-213-1908
same

First Rehabilitation

        T)800-365-4999
F)516-829-1797

W.H. Greene & Associates

T)716-805-1090
F)716-805-1099
same same same  

General Casualty

T)888-737-8256
F)800-461-1645
same same same  

Glatfelter Claims

T)800-233-1957
F)717-747-7051
same same    

Great American

T)888-317-4828
F)888-307-3180
same same same  

Great American Captive

T)877-589-6846 
F)888-223-1317
same same T)877-836-1555  

Hanover

T)800-628-0250  
F)800-399-4734
same same same  

Hanover Glass Claims

T)800-369-4527        

Harleysville

T)800-892-8877   
F)800-441-4118
same same same  

Hartford Insurance

T)888-625-2652
F)800-347-8197
T)800-280-0555
F)860-757-5687
T)888-625-2652
F)800-347-8197
T)800-327-3636
F)800-347-8197
 

Hartford -
Emergency

T)800-243-5860 same same    

Iirving Weber Associates

T)800-243-1811
F)631-913-6028
same same    

Jimcor

T)201-573-8200
F)201-573-8820
same same same  

Liberty Mutual

T)800-22502467 same same same same

Liberty Mutual -
Emergency

T)800-259-2184 same same same same

LoVullo

T)800-876-3065
F)716-856-8057
same same same  

K&K Insurance

T)800-441-3994
F)312-381-9079
same same    

Markel

T)800-362-7535
F)804-747-9367
same same same  

Merchants Insurance

T)800-952-5246
F)716-849-3105
same same same  

Middlesex/Middleoak

T)860-225-2533 opt 7
F)866-514-9861
same same same  

National Benefit Life

        T)800-535-2710
F)800-584-9303

National Grange

T)877-425-2467
F)877-282-3844
same same T)800-962-5515
F)315-434-1429
 

New York State
Insurance Fund

      T)518-437-6400
F)518-437-6946
 

NIF/Berkley Risk

T)800-832-0137
F)712-329-3812
same same    

North Country

T)800-847-7030
F)315-788-4623
same same same  

NYMIR

T)800-696-4705
F)516-222-5392
same same same  

NYMIR -
Emergency after hrs

T)800-894-9341        

Ohio Casualty

T)800-366-6446
F)866-282-5399
same same same  

One Beacon

T)877-248-3455
F)866-213-2802
same same same  

Peerless

T)800-366-6446
F)800-246-0688
same same same  

Peerless -
Emergency

T)800-522-7152 same same same  

Pennsylvania Lumbermans

T)800-752-1895
F)215-829-1211
same same same  

Philadelephia

T)800-765-9749
F)800-685-9238
same same same  

Physicians Reciprocal
(PRI)

         

PMA

T)888-476-2669
F)888-329-2721
same  

T)888-476-2669
F)888-329-2721

 

Preferred Mutual

T)800-333-7642
F)607-847-6616
same same same  

Progressive

T)800-776-2436
Prompt #5
       

Safeco

T)800-332-3226 same same same  

Selective

T)800-568-9656
F)804-422-6135
same same T)866-455-9969  

Selective Emergency

T)866-455-9969
F)877-352-6541
same same same  

S.H. Smith & Co.

T)800-356-0168        

Sterling

T)800-462-4661
F)518-234-8570
same same same  

Thomco

T)678-290-2100
F)678-290-2200
same same same  

Tower

T)888-856-5502
F)212-655-1036
same same same  

Tower -
Emergency after hrs

T)888-250-2317        

Travelers

T)800-238-6225
F)877-784-5329
same same same  

Travelers Glass

T)866-878-4527
F)866-680-3955
       

Trident

T)877-474-8808
F)877-312-8842
same same same  

United Educators

T)301-215-6413
F)301-907-0303
same same same  

Utica Mutual

T)800-365-1914
F)888-538-2018
same same T)800-284-3806  

Vermont Mutual

T)800-451-5000
F)802-229-7647
same same    

Vermont Mutual -
Emergency

T)866-505-2324 
F)802-229-7647
       

York Claims

T)866-338-6787
F)866-336-6787
same same    

Zurich

T)800-239-4559
F)800-887-1335
same same T)800-987-3373
F)877-962-2567
T)800-887-9111
F)631-845-2535

 

 

Personal Insurance Company

Telephone Number

Fax Number

A. Central

T) 866-222-2242

F) 607-965-2252

Adirondack

T) 877-248-0555

F) 866-894-1633

Allstate

T) 800-255-7828

F) 866-259-5200

Central Mutual

T) 800-359-2233

F) 800-877-2293

Central-HURRICANE

T) 877-346-0300

F) 800-736-7026

Donegal

T) 518-239-6020

F) 800-877-8506

Eastern

T) 800-367-3242

F) 518-966-5022

Encompass

T) 800-588-7400

F) 800-426-3692

Erie & Niagara

T) 800-234-9876

F) 716-632-9621

Farmers

T) 800-435-7764

 

GMAC

T) 800-468-3466

F) 800-924-0273

Hanover

T) 800-628-0250

F) 800-399-4734

Hanover Glass Claims

T) 800-369-4527

 

Hartford

T) 800-243-5860

F) 860-757-5687

Kemper/Unitrin

T) 800-357-8999

F) 877-329-5367

Kemper-HURRICANE

T) 888-252-2799

 

Kemper/Unitrin Glass Claims

T) 877-780-3167

 

Liberty Mutual

T) 800-225-2467

F) 518-452-0723

Liberty-HURRICANE

T) 800-259-2184

 

Metlife

T) 800-854-6011

F) 866-743-1546

Mercury

T) 800-503-3724

F) 727-329-7294

National Grange

T) 877-425-2467

F) 877-282-3844

New York Central

T) 800-234-6926

F) 607-965-2136

One Beacon

T) 877-248-4968

F) 866-894-1633

Peerless

T) 800-522-7152

 

Preferred Mutual

T) 800-333-7642

F) 607-847-6616

Progressive

T) 800-274-4499

MUST CALL IN CLAIM

Safeco

T) 800-332-3226

F) 866-378-3661

State Farm

T) 877-208-1487

F) 800-375-3255

Sterling

T) 800-462-4661

F) 518-234-8570

Vermont Mutual

T) 800-451-5000

F) 802-229-7647

Vermont-HURRICANE

T) 800-435-0397

F) 807-229-8941

Travelers

T) 800-252-4633

MUST CALL IN CLAIM